Bella and Jasper?

Did you guys want Jasper to bite Bella? Just curious!

Meh, not really. Probably because, as much as I love Jasper, I think he wouldn't have much self-control at that point, and Bella's existence would...be non-existent. And then Edward would be fairly pissed off, methinks, which generally isn't a great happening.

I agree with evermore. I love Jasper, but I don't think he'd have the self-control to just bite Bella. And I would love to see Edward do it ^_^

Yeah that's what I thought. Me probably wouldn't be able to do it succesfully... And I really want Edward to! I was just wondering cuz I've heard some people say they really wanted him to, and I just wanted to know how many that was!

I agree with all of you...Jaspie wouldn't have the control to stop at just changing Bella. Carlisle would be the best since he's done it several times before and knows what he's doing. But there's something romantic about the person you love doing something so...well...personal. Anyway, my vote goes to Edward biting her. If he can retrain himself while sucking out James's venom, I think he can stop at changing her.

If Jasper were to bite Bella, then she won't feel like she belonged to Edward. She wants Edward to change her so his vemon will make her his in more ways. If Jasper were to do it: one. he might drain her and kill her, and two. Edward would never allow it because he got all pissy when Bella asked Alice to do it.

Jasper is awesome, dont get me wrong, but since he almost bit Bella before, I dont think its really logical for him to bite her.

No, it would have been as amazingly romantic and happy if Jasper bit her than if Edward bit her. Also even if he had then Edward would have tried to save her again.

agreed

Haha, i agree too though

Hey! I am not THAT bad! I agree that it would be very awkward and just not right.

That is how we work here!

But i definitely think it should be ewdard, because anything else would just be weird. It would also be hard for him to control his hunger.

No, given Jasper's past, I don't think he would have the self-control. Besides, Edward biting Bella seems more right...

Eh.

I love love love Jasper, but I think Edward should do it.

It would just make more sense.

And... Jasper might not be able to.. control himself.

but having Jazz nearby (not in the room, of course....not after New Moon!) would be helpful...

it would be? why?

Yeah, I think so.

That makes sense I guess.....

I guess so...!

I totally agree with everyone. Jasper biting Bella will turn the story around and would actually not make it a good story anymore. I mean, I know we're all anticipating the whole part of the series when Edward finally bites Bella and changes her into a vampire. But if Jasper does it as an accident for example then poof! that magical event, that would most likely take up a whole lot of chapters, would be gone! So it's a good thing Jasper didn't bite Bella. XD

no i dont think i want that to happen

ah, our edward fantasies...but what if it was like James? where they removed the venom before it was too late?

but pn the other hand, why would they do that, or why would Bella let them do that is she really wanted to be changed that badly.

Bella: *walking upstairs to Edward's room*

Jasper: *walks by* ........ *CHOMP*

Bella: O_O?!

I think it would be cool if Jasper was in the room 'cause then he could calm Edward down if he starts going nuts. But, then again, Jazz might go nuts himself... Hm...

it could always be an accident, but i doubt it would happen after NM...but what if he did bite her in NM?

I think it would be interesting but she wouldn't feel as attatched to Edward....... I think that's how that would have turned out..... and then Jacob never would have been there.... I could work with that..... :)