So, don't you love Rosalie?

I just think Rosalie is selfish but she doesn't bother Edward and Bella she just trys to help Bella. She isn't bad. I like her, but I don't love her. :)

OMG how can anyone not like rosalie she's like a watermelon hard and fierce and scary on the outside but sweet sorry and nice on the inside

rosalie is a good charector in the book

Yah she is selfish and all she does is think about her self and so yah but she is really nice to Bella! :)

See, that's not a reaction I see much.

People say she's a bitch to Bella. Which she is, but Bella's a bitch back so it evens out.

And in Eclipse she really is nice.

So LIKE HER OR DIE!!!!

I feel like people hold back on the Rose hate in this thread just because I'm so intense about my hatred of Rose haters. Don't do that.

I agree with Twirls about everything she said above. Yes,
she has been kinda bitchy. But hasn't she been through a lot? How
would you people feel if you had everything you wanted
within reach, but your soon-to-be husband got drunk AND
MURDERED YOU? Then, after you got changed, your
"brother" doesn't like you very much and instead falls in
love with some plain simpleton, and spills all of his- and
not to mention your- secrets out to her? Pretty much all
Rosie has going for her is her beauty, and everyone
around her seems to be ignoring that. Poor Rosalie...

I HATE ROSALIE HATE. THAT SIMPLE. I'M WITH TWIRLS.

YES!

And like Sonia said, all she has going for her is her beauty.
And people turn it against her and call her vain and selfish and ridiculous.
She's not.
She's damaged.
So (insert four letter expletive here) you Rose haters.

I do like her because she just wants Bella to make the right decision and I like that about her. She doesn't really bother anyone and I think you just need to get to know her to really like her.

Bella923 wrote:

Can i help i HATE Rosalie!

WTF!?!?!?!?!?!?

That's ridiculous.

What cause do you have for that, Bella?

I thought better of you.

The head of Jasper, no less!

And my aunt!

I'm disappointed.

Very disappointed.

And it's not just you.

I mean really, PLANNING HER MURDER?

How immature and ridiculous can you get?

Ugh.

Pisses me off.

ok so i was reading this but its 16 pages and ahh i'm lazy so now i'm just going to post what i think of rose.
ok so at first i really hated rose i thought she was so mean and such a bitch... then i got really mad at her when she told edward about bella grr. but then i read how guilty she felt and that she wanted to go to Italy to stop him and she only wanted him(edward) to come home, she would of never guessed that he would try and kill himself. so i was like ok she isn't that bad. then i was mad again when she voted no, then she explained her self and i was like ok she doesn't want bella's life to be like her own still mad not as much but still.
then i read eclipse and chapter 7 which if you don't know is the one in which she tells bella her story of when she was human. (bastard fiancee). and that is when my hate completely went away. she isn't selfish or mean she just wants to protect her family and herself from harm she's just a lil more over protective which is why she didn't like bella at the beginning in my opinion. she doesn't want to be hurt she doesn't want bella to get hurt.
she doesn't want bella to look back and think of what a mistake she made (in rose's opinion)... by giving it all up. but she is trying to let bella have what she wants and let her pick for her self. it's just hard to see someone give it all up when its the one thing in the world you want... all she wants is humanity and she sees bella giving it up as being silly and wasteful but she is trying to be ok with it. this is long but one more thing and i think i'm done her and Emmett make the perfect pair...even in the movie they look awesome together.
oh one more thing please no hate on nikki she is awesome and very pretty she will do great...alot of nikki hate when she was picked i hope people love her now....sorry i tend to rant... oh and sorry for any grammar or spelling mistakes its one in the morning so yeah.

GO STEPH! You're an awesomeness daughter. (and part of the reason it's hard to read is because madz used to post here a lot)

Nikki wasn't my first choice, or really my choice at all, but I think she'll do okay. I like her as an actress, (she was in Thirteen with Evan Rachel Wood, who was in ATU with *swoon* Jim Sturgess) but I don't think she's Rosalie. Of course, Rosalie doesn't have a huge part in Twilight, so she'll probably do pretty well.

i love how you found a way to bring in ATU you are a master at it :).
and yeah she will do fine like at first i was really upset but then i started watching some of her movies and shes good and then the interviews with her on mtv. she seems so sweet and nice and i loved her. i love the chemistry between her and kellan its awesome lol kellan is hot.

KELLAN IS AMAZINGLY HOT! And he'll be an amazing Emmett.

And steph. I can bring ATU into anything. It's a skill, and I've perfected it. Did you know Ashley Greene (Alice) was also in a movie with Evan Rachel Wood (lucy)?

i've noticed you can :) did you do alot of research on the people in the movie or how did you find all this out?

I really have no idea, I just pick up any piece of information about it that I hear, read, or see.

I didn't LIKE her but i didn't HATE her either .. i just barely cared ..

Ah well, thats still better than hating her.

I actually do like Rosalie. She is definitely misunderstood, and I never did actually hate her at any point in the books. Rose is actually a good person if you look past the vain, jealous facade that is originally setup.

yeah she is but people don't see that because they rarely look past her being vain they get stuck there and don't even give her a chance even after reading about how sad her past was they still hate her cause she can be a lil mean

everyone can be a little mean

even bella, who everyone seems to view as perfect

i'm going to be perfectly honest.

bella is really annoying sometimes.

maybe that's why I identify so strongly with Rose...

I agree, i think that Bella can get annoying, especially in the third one.

No one is perfect, and I really do like Rosalie, because despite her flaws, she really does mean well, or at least i think so.

bella isn't perfect i hated the part at the end of the 3rd book but i still love her.
but i am more like rose i am a bit bitchy sometimes but i still love people its just takes more than just a hi to get into my heart

I am with you steph (or at least the first part)

I am actually not a lot like Rosalie, but I can see her point of view.

Rosalie isn't bad. She wants to help Bella. Once you know where she's coming from I got a hole different prespective.

rosalie just puzzles me greatly.
but i feel for her.
she is my beautiful vamp sister, and i love her with all my heart!

I never hated Rosalie. I think that becasue of how she was raised before she was a vampire, is how she thinks she should act. Also, she does have a lot to be mad about. Like why she became a vampire. I defiantly wouldn't be miss Sunshine if someone did that to me.