A Little Advise for Those who claimed to hate it!

I just don't find BD to be my favorite. I cant see it as part of the Twiight Saga because it just doesn't FIT. It was okay, and had some really good moments, but.... Its not that great.

I read it twice and still didn't like it....
way to like a fanfic for me.
and I don't know I am just so over happy endings.

When I read BD, I really liked it at first, then I did not, and now I am undecided. My aunt has borrowed it, so I have not reread it yet, but when I get it back, i fully intend to.

thats is a good idea

I didn't really like B.D. all that much as part of the twilight series, but alone as a book I enjoyed it :)

On one hand, I hated it. It was realllly formulaic, and it seemed like a lot of things just happened to happen, instead of furthering the plot at all. Some parts of the book made me want to get out my red pen and start marking all of the things that were messed up. Lol.

On the other hand, I thought it was pretty much the best it could be. If all of the ends hadn't been tied up, if Bella and Edward and Jake hadn't all ended up happy...well, that wouldn't have been good. So it definitiely worked that way.

it was pretty good, but it just seemed to drag on and on

Happy endings where the hero gets everything it a HUGE pet peeve of mine. I just think it's so stupid becuase things never happen like that. Yes I know its fantasy but all good writers know the protagonist has to lose something to make for a good ending.

Yes, I like to think that the series ends with Eclipse as well.

grr I read it six times and the happy ending still bugs me! someone should have died.... a main character should have died the fight should have has action! it should not have been like in kindergarden where you use only your words!

the violence! XD